This paper explores the criticism of Mahendra Singh Dhoni, a celebrated figure in Indian cricket, over his selective silence on key social and cultural issues. While he has been vocal about certain matters, his lack of engagement with important Indian festivals like Diwali and significant events such as the death of actor Sushant Singh Rajput has led to public disillusionment. Fans and critics have accused him of prioritizing commercial endorsements over emotional and cultural responsibilities, questioning his commitment to his roots. This study examines the implications of Dhoni’s actions on his public image and the broader debate surrounding celebrity responsibility in society.