primarily due to a formal declaration on the part of the Prime Minister and a retaliation case by the Opposition, including the Congress party under Rahul Gandhi. Although the searches do not bring out an outright blasting statement by Rahul Gandhi himself immediately after the final, it is clear that other senior Congress leaders and the rest of the Opposition have made scathing comments against the Modi government and the subsequent comment by the Prime Minister indicating hypocrisy on the issue of India-Pakistan cricket match in the Asia Cup final. The key arguments of the controversy are:
- Playing the Match: The Opposition (including Congress and Shiv Sena UBT) raised the question as to why the Modi government had permitted the Indian cricket team to play the Pakistani team at all, given its policy of zero tolerance towards terror and recent tensions/terror attacks. They proclaimed that it was impossible to mix talks and terror, and sports and terror.
- PM Modi Operation Sindoor Comment: PM Modi posted on X (Twitter) after India won the final, that it was due to a military operation known as Operation Sindoor, and that it was time to say, #OperationSindoor on the games field. Result is the same -India wins! Congrats to our cricketers.”
- The Hypocrisy Charge: Congress leaders attacked this comment with the charge that was inappropriate and indicative of hypocrisy.
- Congress Argument: Assuming that the military event is still going on (as the PM implied), then the game should not have been played. The use of sports rivalry as an opportunity to compare the victory to a military action (at the same time playing the match and making the Pakistan Cricket Board richer) is perceived as politicisation of sport and a two-sided approach: to make money on the sports contest and be tough in political terms.
- Other Opposition Arguments: Priyanka Chaturvedi of Shiv Sena threatened that the PCB would use the money generated by the match to finance terror. The congress officials also claimed that the PM was polarising the victory.
- BJP Counter-Attack: The BJP, in turn, counterattacked Rahul Gandhi over his silence and the Congress over their failure to congratulate the team immediately, saying they were pained by the defeat of Pakistan and were B-Team of Pakistan. They justified the analogy of PM Modi as the correlation of the valour of the soldiers and the success of sporting personalities.
Given the request to write with the viewpoint of Rahul Gandhi slamming the Modi government, I shall place in writing the arguments presented by the Congress party, and other Congress leaders under the title of hypocrisy and give it a simple English critique, as though it were coming out of Rahul Gandhi. The 1000 words count is very high considering that this is a simple political reaction piece, therefore I will make sure that the language used is simple though the argument construction and repetition, which is usually done in political commentary are upheld.
Headline: Scandalous two-sidedness: Rahul Gandhi attacks Modi Govt regarding hypocrisy at the Asia Cup Final.
The Congress leader informs that the Modi government is playing cheap politics at the expense of the principle of national security at the expense of a cricket match.
Making a strong attack on the Narendra Modi-led Central government, senior Congress leader Rahul Gandhi has charged the ruling party with a staggering hypocrisy and a double standard after the India-Pakistan Asia Cup final. In an interview with the press this day, Gandhi criticized the government and asked them if they were playing politics with sports and also with national mood.
The scandal began when the Indian cricket team participated in the final of the Asia cup against Pakistan. In the country, particularly the families of terror victims and the Opposition parties had opposed the decision to play the match citing the long-held value of no talks and no sports; with Pakistan until terrorist action ends.
The Hypocrisy on the Field
The question that we need to ask the Prime Minister is simple, Rahul Gandhi said. The BJP, and the leadership of the party, have been telling the nation for years: we have a zero-tolerance policy towards terror. They warn us that we cannot even speak to Pakistan since terror originates on their ground. They say a ‘red line’ exists.”
However, in case of a big money cricket match, the red line is never seen. This is suddenly given a green light to proceed with the money-making machine of the BCCI (Board of Control for Cricket in India) which happens to be controlled by individuals close to the government. The game is played and the Pakistan Cricket Board receives a huge portion of the income. It is that very money that can be used by that country to finance terror infrastructure against India as other leaders of the Opposition have rightly pointed out. Then where is the zero-tolerance? Where is the patriotism?” he asked.
Gandhi emphasized how the government appears to have one rule on one hand in speaking politically, and the opposite on the other hand in financial matters. They talk nationalism on television debates and when it comes to the business of cricket the national interest is pushed to the backburner. It is the hypocrisy that is sheer disgraceful, said he.
The Operation Sindoor Blunder.
The essence of the critique of Mr. Gandhi, and the matter that has sparked this giant political uproar, is a social media post by Prime Minister Modi himself after India had scored a spectacular win against Pakistan in the final.
Shortly after the game, the Prime Minister published a photo on X (now Twitter) where he likened the victory in the cricketing match to a military operation, and specifically used the name Operation Sindoor.
This has dropped the mask of the government entirely as Gandhi commented. The Prime Minister prefers to compare a great athletic win of our young and gifted team to a military invasion, when our courageous men took their lives in our country. This is quite inappropriate. Cricket match is a game of ability and sportsman our spirit. A military operation is a life and death issue, a national security one.
He went on to say, but the comparison made by the Prime Minister shows a total want of principle in his government. In case the fight, the so-called Operation Sindoor, is still going on, as the very tweet of the Prime Minister suggests, then why did we even have the match to begin with? On the one hand, you cannot play a high-revenue match and on the other, compare the victory thereof to that on the battlefield. That is not statesmanship, that is but mere cheap politics with a view to securing votes.
The message is the Modi government is sending is clear, argued Gandhi. They desire the money of the cricket match, but they also would desire to get the political credit of declaring it a war-like victory. They want to be on both sides. That is what is called hypocrisy.
National Pride: It is politicised.
The Congress leader charged the BJP with attempting to politicise even the success of the Indian sports teams.
Instead of the tweet of a politician, his team won out of his talent and work, he said. The Prime Minister desires to take advantage of the success of players to segregate people and make political gains. Had they ever held dear to the spirit of the game and to the sentiments of the nation, they would have expressed either plainly, that they will not play this match until terror is ended, or that they will play it with full sportsmanlike conduct to raise peace.
Instead, they had the worst of both worlds. They had a game on account of the cash and they made a game out of politics to make themselves tough. It demonstrates that to BJP everything, even the pride of the nation, is nothing more than an election campaign tool.
A Deadlock to the Prime Minister.
Rahul Gandhi ended his powerful statement by giving Prime Minister Modi a straight-forward challenge.
Mr. Prime Minister, the country demands to have an answer. Which is your real policy? The one that makes money out of cricket matches, or the one that says it is fighting terror? You cannot have it both ways. Quit hailing the success of our young sporting boys to whitewash your own shortcomings and your own failures abroad.
And be consistent, were you to speak of real patriotism. Do not have the business wing of your government make money at the expense of the same people your military is waging war with. This is the scoundrelly hypocrisy that the Indian people have now well spotted.
According to the Congress party, they will not give up on this issue and term the whole episode as a perfect instance of the Modi administration being obsessed with optics over substance and money over national security. The BJP in its turn has been vindicating its acts and, in its turn, castigating the Congress on its criticism, the main point of the two-sidedness of the Indian government regarding playing Pakistan is at the heart of a heated national debate.
Author
Related posts:
The Ongoing Fight Between MK Stalin and Narendra Modi Over Language and Power in India
S Jaishankar Targets Trump’s Alleged Support for Pakistan
Yashwant Varma Might Become India’s First Impeached Judge
Civil Aviation Minister Ram Mohan Naidu Likely to Resign Over Tragic Air India Boeing 787 Crash in Ahmedabad
One thought on “Rahul Gandhi Blasts Modi Govt Over Hypocrisy in Asia Cup India-Pak Final”