The U.S. support for Canada in the ongoing dispute with India over the Nijjar killing is rooted in a complex web of intelligence sharing, strategic alliances, and domestic political considerations. As a member of the Five Eyes alliance, the U.S. has a responsibility to stand by its partners, particularly when serious allegations of extrajudicial killings are involved. At the same time, the U.S. is wary of jeopardizing its strategic relationship with India, a critical ally in its Indo-Pacific strategy. The challenge for Washington is to balance these competing interests while continuing to uphold its values of justice and accountability on the global stage.