
Govt of India Considering a Ban on Instant Delivery Apps Like Instamart, Zepto and Blinkit
A move that may change the gig economy scenario forever, the Government of India may ban instant delivery apps like Blinkit, Instamart, and Zepto. Platforms like Blinkit, Instamart, and Zepto have changed consumer shopping behavior with promises to get groceries and other essentials delivered in mere minutes, but with steep ascent comes challenges especially for gig workers.
This paper discusses how instant delivery applications are on the rise, changing consumers’ lives and working conditions of people, as well as implications if such apps were banned in a country.
The Rise of Instant Delivery Apps
One has seen in the last three years widespread popularity of apps Blinkit, Zepto, and Instamart among others. Their USPs are speed wherein they promise that delivery will arrive in as soon as 10 minutes, making it convenient for metro consumers who work long hours for quick delivery-through technology with efficient supply chains, these models have changed buying habits, that is, buy on impulse last minute.
However, behind the slick marketing and tech-savvy operations lies a workforce of gig workers bearing the brunt of this convenience-driven model. While consumers benefit from faster deliveries, gig workers often face grueling conditions to meet the tight deadlines.
Impact on Gig Workers
On the other hand, instant delivery applications rely more on gig workers for their core services. The people are considered independent contractors and get paid per delivery as opposed to getting a fixed salary. The model is flexible, but at an enormous cost.
1. Unrealistic Delivery Timelines
Tight deadlines pressure workers to trade in safety for speed. Most reports indicate that many workers adopt unsafe driving behaviors, such as speeding or violation of traffic laws, to beat delivery targets.
This has caused a rise in road accidents involving delivery riders, which further raises concerns on worker and public safety.
2. Stress and Mental Health
Constant stress about meeting deadlines along with the vagaries of income generation puts immense pressure on the minds of the gig workers. IFAT (Indian Federation of App-Based Transport Workers) finds that most of the workers are overworked, underpaid, and left without much time for rest.
3. Low Wages and Lack of Benefits
While the services promise competitive income, the ground reality is a far cry. Many gig workers end up getting paid less than the minimum wage after accounting for fuel and maintenance costs.
What is worse, they are termed independent contractors, which means that they do not get benefits such as health insurance, paid leaves, or security of employment. This precarious condition makes them more susceptible to insecurity.
4. Exploitation by Classification
Classification of workers as contractors skips the labor laws of employees by companies. It also means they do not have to give any of the minimum rights workers demand, such as a fixed wage, overtime pay or rights in the workplace. Advocates term it an exploitative model. The profits are channeled upwards to corporate centers.
Gig Economy in India: Facts and Figures
The gig economy in India has grown significantly. Reports suggest that, in 2020-21, the sector accommodated as many as 7.7 million workers. NITI Aayog says it may touch an enormous number by 2029-30 as high as 23.5 million.
Here are the prime contributors: some of the prime contributors include platforms such as Blinkit, Zepto, and Instamart which accommodate thousands of delivery workers.
Despite the fact that the gig sector is expanding, average earnings levels for gig workers remain very low.
According to a recent survey by Fairwork India, most workers now earn between ₹10,000 and ₹15,000 per month – earnings levels far too low to meet good standards of living in metro cities. Also, while more than 80% of gig workers reported more than 10 hours of working daily, which is a massive burden.
Possible Consequences of a Ban
If the Government of India moves forward with the decision to ban instant delivery apps, the repercussions will be enormous:
1. For Workers
Thousands of gig workers will lose their jobs as their main source of income is being taken away.
Although the jobs are far from ideal, many workers in a country where formal employment opportunities are limited rely on such earnings for survival.
2. For Consumers
Consumers, especially city dwellers, have become too accustomed to instant delivery. A blanket ban would then disrupt their mode of shopping so that they begin to plan purchases ahead and revert to traditional, longer delivery mechanisms.
3. For the Economy
The Indian economy is very well supported by the economy of gigs; a ban here would be nothing but slow up this sector affecting the other services like logistics and warehousing together with the aspect of technology itself.
4. For Organizations
Instant delivery applications may also suffer from heavy economic losses and loss of reputation. Such an investment in this venture may be lost to the investors and ultimately impact the Indian startup space.
Alternative Solutions
In addition to a complete ban, there are other ways in which the challenge that these instant delivery apps pose can be met without infringing labor rights:
1. Strengthen Labor Laws
The government can create laws that ensure fair wages, benefits, and job security for gig workers. This can be achieved by reclassifying the workers as employees and giving them legal protections.
2. Tighter Timelines
Setting minimum delivery timelines will reduce the pressure on gig workers. For instance, deliveries can be capped at a minimum of 30 minutes, where the worker is allowed to focus on safety over speed.
3. Mandatory Benefits
The health insurance, paid leave, and retirement benefits for all gig workers would be the mandates of the companies, no matter how their employment is categorized.
4. Ethical Business Practices
Transparency in payments, grievance redressal mechanism, or engaging with the labor unions/worker advocacy groups must be the minimum expectation from such platforms.
5. Public Awareness
Consumers can act by choosing to stand behind the platforms that work with ethical labor. Awareness campaigns regarding the actuality of gig work can make consumers be more careful with their purchases.
It would not be so easy to bring a ban; the instant delivery apps have given Indians a taste for new, more convenient habits of shopping and much else, which they would resent if suddenly restricted.
But harming workers, consumers, and the economy would remain on the agenda instead. What the country needs are better labour laws and ethics in business practice while stricter regulation as well to balance the growth with sustainability and ensuring that this sector protects the rights and dignity of gig workers too.
India, by boldly attacking these challenges, would present a model of how innovation without abandoning equity and inclusion can occur to the entire world.
Stay Connected and Share Your Stories
For all those inspired by stories of resilience and ambition, follow us on X/Twitter at https://x.com/ThePhilox and on Instagram at https://www.instagram.com/philoxbox/. For those with untold stories that you would love to share, please send them to contact@thephilox.com
1 thought on “Govt of India Considering a Ban on Instant Delivery Apps Like Instamart, Zepto and Blinkit”