The Indian film industry has long borne witness to an intriguing paradox: critically acclaimed films often fail at the box office, while those dismissed by the critics go on to become blockbuster hits.
In recent times, this trend has been seen with the unexpected success of Badass Ravi Kumar, an action spectacle that defies logic and storytelling conventions, as opposed to All We Imagine as Light, an Oscar-nominated film that has failed to generate the same level of public interest.
Although it is criticized for an incoherent plot, it has still drawn huge crowds, yet the other one with a globally recognized is not heard of by the masses. What may be the possible reasons behind such differences?
Marketing strategies, star power, genre appeal, cultural preferences, social media influence, audience expectations, and word-of-mouth dynamics are just some of the reasons.
Marketing Strategies and Star Power: The Battle for Attention
Marketing goes a long way in determining what any movie would be. Aggressive marketing over various media such as television, radio, digital media, and even social networking sites immensely benefited the film Badass Ravi Kumar.
All that was left was to hammer down the point through posters and trailers portraying its high energy action and witty dialogues as something to be seen and hence to appeal to the masses.
A crucial element in the film’s success was the presence of Himesh Reshammiya, a singer-turned-actor with a cult following.
His return to the big screen sparked curiosity, drawing both his dedicated fanbase and audiences intrigued by his larger-than-life persona.
The film’s marketing played heavily on this nostalgia and curiosity, ensuring maximum visibility.
In sharp contrast, All We Imagine as Light pursued a much more limited marketing campaign.
A more word-of-mouth approach, which relied more on the prestige of its festival placement and serious media reviews rather than mass advertising, kept it within just the circle where it could accrue prestige. The mainstream had little chance of knowing it was out there.
Without a big star and an all-out promo push, the buzz outside those niches was severely limited.
Genre Appeal and Cultural Preferences: The Entertainment Quotient
The genre of a film plays a significant role in determining its audience reach. Badass Ravi Kumar belongs to the masala film genre—a long-standing staple of Indian cinema known for its mix of action, drama, romance, and music.
This type of cinema thrives on exaggerated storytelling, defying conventional logic in favor of pure entertainment.
For most Indian audiences, films have been a kind of escape; they provide big-screen experiences and transport them from their mundane battles.
Badass Ravi Kumar capitalizes on this demand, offering high-octane action, loud music, and some absurd comedy—a package that mass audiences have generally liked over time.
All We Imagine as Light is an introspective, slow-paced narrative that touches deep emotional themes. While critically acclaimed in storytelling and cinematography, it doesn’t align with mainstream audiences’ expectation of escapism.
In general, Indian audiences have preferred spectacle-driven films to deeply emotionally involved ones. The artistic nature of the film while being appreciated in film festivals doesn’t resonate with the entertainment-driven consumption culture of the majority.
The Role of Social Media and Memes: Virality vs. Prestige
In today’s digital era, social media has become an influential force in shaping audience perceptions. The rise of meme culture has created a new avenue for films to gain traction, even when critical reception is negative.
This phenomenon proved a boon for Badass Ravi Kumar. This means the melodramatic dialogues, hyperbolic action scenes, and unintentional comedy meant that there was no dearth of meme material.
In this movie, the “cringe-worthy” moments of the film was picked up by the internet as an ironic celebration, which in effect helped its reach.
Viral content, whether satirical or not, encourages more people to see it for themselves-people streaming into theatres to experience the same. More often than not it was mocked all the more just to see that for themselves-the houseful’s.
On the other hand, All We Imagine as Light hardly lent itself at all to memetic socializing. It barely had any juicy sensational content attached to it at all. Of course, by virtue of which, it saw little or next to no lift in mainstream consciousness.
Audience Expectations and Word-of-Mouth: Fulfilling the Promise
Success for a film is often measured by whether it meets the expectations of the audience. Badass Ravi Kumar was marketed as an outrageous action flick, and it delivered exactly that.
The viewers who walked in expecting mindless entertainment were not disappointed, and hence, positive word-of-mouth spread among those who value fun over logic.
This organic promotion played a crucial role in sustaining the film’s box office run.
The other one, All We Imagine as Light, built the audience’s expectations for a deep cinematic experience.
Even though it met that depth in terms of quality, the general audience, educated to believe that entertainment should be fast-moving, had not prepared mentally for such a level of depth and slow storytelling.
Consequently, it failed to create hype in terms of general recommendations, but only cinephiles who attended the festivals appreciated it.
Word-of-mouth is a double-edged sword. While positive buzz can elevate a film’s success, a lack of strong audience endorsements can limit its reach.
Since Badass Ravi Kumar was enjoyed for what it was—an absurd yet entertaining ride—it saw sustained attendance.
Meanwhile, All We Imagine as Light remained confined to select intellectual circles, preventing it from gaining momentum among casual moviegoers.
The Power of Nostalgia and the Demand for Escapism
The power of nostalgia is another key reason why these films have fared so differently. Badass Ravi Kumar plays off the nostalgic value of the masala film, embracing those very tropes that made action films in the 80s and 90s iconic.
The self-awareness of being over-the-top allows audiences to enjoy the ridiculousness rather than criticize it.
By contrast, All We Imagine as Light presents a realistic, emotionally complex narrative. While this approach is undoubtedly valuable in artistic terms, it does not align with the entertainment-driven expectations of many Indian viewers.
Films that focus on realism demand emotional investment, something that mainstream audiences are often unwilling to give, particularly when they seek entertainment as a form of escapism.
The Business of Entertainment vs. Art
The contrasting box office performances of Badass Ravi Kumar and All We Imagine as Light underscore the ongoing struggle between artistic cinema and mass-market entertainment.
While critical acclaim and international recognition add prestige, they do not necessarily translate into financial success.
The Indian film industry works in such a manner that it usually depends on a movie’s commercial viability in entertaining, marketing itself aggressively, and generating viral social media engagement.
While art-house films win accolades, they need to find new ways of connecting with a wider audience for box office success.
Ultimately, filmmakers have to strike a balance between creative storytelling and market realities. They know that while artistic integrity is important, engaging the audience is the foundation of commercial filmmaking.
Stay Connected and Share Your Stories
For all those inspired by stories of resilience and ambition, follow us on X/Twitter and on Instagram . For those with untold stories that you would love to share, please send them to contact@thephilox.com
